Secret Santa and White Elephant Scarves
A scarf is one of the safest Secret Santa gifts because it fits everyone and gets used. For white elephant, a fun print can be the gift people steal.
For someone you barely know
Neutral knits in grey, navy, oatmeal or a classic plaid work for nearly anyone.
White elephant
A playful print or bright color gets laughs and still gets worn.
Ask the SI concierge
We’ve pre-filled it for you. Edit the sentence with details about your person for three scarf ideas, each with a reason it fits and a button to real listings from independent makers.
Try one of these:
How to choose
- Stick to the budget, usually $25 to $30.
- Unisex colors keep it safe.
- Wrap it nicely; presentation counts in a swap.
- Order by early December.
Skip these
Skip very personal items, strong scents and jokes that could offend.
Shop real scarves from makers
We may earn a commission when you buy through our links.
See real plaid scarf options on Etsy See real knit scarf unisex options on Etsy See real novelty print scarf options on Etsy
Prices, shipping, sizing and returns are set by each Etsy seller, so check the listing before you buy.
Read more on the blog
FAQ
Is a scarf a good Secret Santa gift?
Yes. It fits everyone, works for most budgets and gets used in winter.
Where do these come from?
Every button opens a live Etsy search, so you see real scarves from independent makers and vintage sellers, with photos, reviews and prices. You buy from the seller; we may earn a commission.